Slice of Heaven: Best Pizza in Fredericksburg, Spotsy & Stafford!

There's a lot of competition for best pizza in our area, but here are some of our favorites

By Jenny Sites February 8, 2024

Oh, pizza. How we adore you! Whether it's a busy weeknight or a lazy weekend, pizza always comes to the rescue. Plus, who can resist that heavenly combination of melted cheese, savory toppings, and a perfectly crispy crust? We certainly can't!

🍕 Pass me another slice, please.

We are incredibly fortunate to have many fantastic locally-owned pizza joints right here in Fredericksburg, Spotsylvania, and Stafford, ready to satisfy our every pizza craving. We ask YOU to vote for your favorites, so join us on a mouthwatering journey through your top picks for the best pizza in Fredericksburg, Spotsylvania, and Stafford:

Brother's Pizza | Facebook

1. Brother's Pizza

📍 Address: 3605 Plank Rd, Fredericksburg

What you love: The pizza is always fresh with just the right amount of sauce. "Closest to NY-style pizza outside of NYC"

 Benny Vitali | Facebook

2. Benny Vitali's

📍 Address: 722 Caroline Street, Fredericksburg

What you love: HUGE slices and great topping combinations!

Jen's Pizza Den | Facebook

3. Jen's Pizza Den

📍 Address: 175 Cambridge St, Fredericksburg

What you love: It's an "Old-School pizzeria" with delicious pizza.

Vinny's | Facebook

4. Vinny's Italian Grill

📍 Address: 11105 Leavells Rd #5087, Fredericksburg

📍 Address: 201 Kings Hwy, Fredericksburg

📍 Address: 20 Plantation Dr, Fredericksburg

📍 Address: 397 Garrisonville Rd, Stafford

What you love: With multiple locations in our area, you are never far from this yummy pizza.

George's Pizza| Facebook

5. George's Pizza

📍 Address: 5306 Plank Rd, Fredericksburg 

What you love: Celebrating its 50th year in business this year, this pizza parlor has great pizza and fun memories!

Jyliana | Canva Pro

Honorable Mentions: 

  • My Little Italy: "Great staff with amazing pizza."
  • Danny's Pizza: "Great pizza, plus it's BOGO."
  • Marco's: "Great Value and always delicious." 
  • Primavera Pizza: Always Fresh and tasty.
  • Malawi's: "Brick oven, friendly staff & donation made for every entree."
  • Orifino: "Pizza Margherita is the best I've ever tasted."
  • Angela's: "Perfect crust, fantastic sauce"
  • Sam's Pizza: "Best pizza I've ever had" with multiple locations.
  • Ledo's Pizza: " Flaky crust, sauce is amazing."
  • LaDelizia: "Most authentic NY pizza around."